Top Over/Under Sportsbooks in New York: Where to Bet Totals in 2025

If you’re only betting the moneyline, you’re missing half the fun. Totals betting—also known as Over/Under—is one of the most exciting and straightforward ways to get in on the action. Rather than betting who wins, you’re predicting the total number of points, goals, or runs scored in a game.

Every licensed New York online sportsbook offers Totals markets across a wide range of sports, including football, basketball, baseball, hockey, and more. Below, we’ll break down the top NY sportsbooks for Over/Under betting, highlight welcome bonuses, and show you which sports you can bet Totals on.

Top Totals (Over/Under) Sportsbooks

Sportsbook	Bonus	Totals Betting Markets
ESPN bet	Get $1,000 In Bonuses	Tennis, football, soccer, basketball, baseball, hockey, MMA, golf, college sports
FanDuel	Bet $5, Win $250 in bonus bets	Tennis, WNBA, soccer, MLB, baseball, hockey, MMA, golf, college sports
Fanatics	Bet $10, Get $20 in bonus bets	Football, soccer, basketball, baseball, hockey, MMA, golf, tennis, college sports
BetRivers	Second chance bet up to $100	Tennis, football, soccer, basketball, baseball, hockey, MMA, golf, college sports
DraftKings	Bet $5, get $200 + $1,000 deposit offer	Tennis, UFC, soccer, basketball, baseball, hockey, MMA, golf, college sports, rugby
Caesars	Bet $1, Get Ten 100% Profit Boosts	Tennis, football, soccer, basketball, baseball, hockey, MMA, golf, college sports
Bally Bet	Bet $10, get $50 in bonus bets	Football, soccer, cricket, baseball, hockey, MMA, golf, Tennis, college sports

What is Totals Betting?

The Totals bet is a great alternative to Moneyline wagers. Instead of betting on which team or player will win, you simply bet on how many points will be scored during a game. More specifically, you bet on whether the total points or goals will be over or under the sportsbook’s point. 

Example: Milwaukee Bucks are playing at Boston Celtics. The sportsbook sets the Totals mark at:

Over 212.0 points: -110
Under 212.0 points: -110

Therefore, if the game finished 103-101, the total would be 204. The Under 212 bet would therefore win. It doesn’t matter who wins the game, just the total number of points. 

A Totals bet is great if you like following high-scoring sides (or low-scoring ones). You can make a bet based on the knowledge of which sides are likely to rack up the slam dunks and big touchdowns. 

Available Sports for Totals (Over/Under)

Over/Under Totals betting is available at all good New York sportsbooks. You can bet on many different sports – in fact, any sport that uses conventional points scoring. 

Football

Football is by far the biggest betting market at New York sportsbooks. You can bet on all NFL games and most college football (NCAAF) games too. But why settle for just total points in a game? Sportsbooks offer prices on total team points, total passing yards, and even whether the total points tally will be odd or even.

• Total points
• Total points odd/even
• Total team points
• Total team points odd/even
• Total passing yards
• Total rushing yards
• Total receiving yards 

Basketball

NY sportsbooks offer odds on NBA basketball and college basketball across the board. 

• Total points
• Points during periods
• Total team points
• Total player points

Baseball

You can bet on baseball markets throughout the season. Baseball lends itself well to Totals markets due to the huge array of stats and scores that you can find. 

• Total Runs in a Game
• Total Team Runs
• Total Team Odd/Even
• 1^st Inning Total
• 1^st Inning Total Odd/Even

Hockey

From the regular season to the Stanley Cup, New York online sportsbooks have odds on all Totals markets. You can bet on total goals (over/under) and total goals including OT and Pens (if applicable). You can also bet on 1^st, 2^nd and 3^rd period totals. 

• Total Goals (Over/Under)
• Total Goals (inc. OT and Pens)
• Total Team Goals
• 1^st Period Total Goals
• 2^nd Period Total Goals
• 3^rd Period Total Goals

Best NY Sportsbooks for Totals Betting

You can wager on Totals (over/under bets) at all nine legal mobile sportsbooks in New York—as long as you’re 21 or older, located physically inside New York State, and using an official app or website.

Fanatics Sportsbook

Launched in NY on February 29, 2024, Fanatics offers a clean, fan-centric interface and a compelling FanCash rewards system—convertible to team gear through Fanatics.com. It’s earned top marks for growth and live‑betting capabilities among NY users.

ESPN Bet

The newest player to join in late September 2024, ESPN Bet (powered by PENN) rounds out the nine‐operator field. . It integrates ESPN insights, a crisp UX, and currently runs welcome offers like ‘bet $10, get $100 in bonus bets + 30 days of ESPN+. As of its debut, it handles a modest but growing share of market volume

Caesars Sportsbook

With its sleek interface and powerful live‐betting suite, Caesars consistently ranks among New Yorkers’ top picks. As an official New York Mets partner, it offers 10× 100% profit boosts with a $1 stake and lets you earn Caesars Rewards for every bet, redeemable across Caesars Resorts and more.

BetMGM

Active in NY since early 2022, BetMGM brings solid market depth, competitive odds, and a polished mobile experience. You accumulate BetMGM Rewards, and you can also link your account to MGM Resorts loyalty—clearing the way for perks at partner hotels and casinos.

FAQs