21+ · 1-877-8-HOPENY Today's Promo Codes
News

Why Some NY Sportsbooks Hold More Than Others: What the Weekly Data Says

By NY.Bet TeamUpdated
ny-sportsbook-hold-weekly-data

FanDuel kept 12.1% of the $226.5 million New Yorkers bet with it in the week ending October 18. BetRivers kept 5.7%. Same games, same week, same state. The New York State Gaming Commission’s latest weekly report showed the eight mobile sportsbooks taking $615.1 million in bets and holding $63.3 million, a 10.3% win rate. That was the first double-digit week of the NFL season and the highest hold since mid-August. The gap between operators isn’t random, and it says a lot about where bettors get value.

FanDuel NY Sportsbook · 9.3/10
Get $350 in Bonus Bets When You Wager $5 for 7 Days ($50 in Bonus Bets per day)
New customers. $50 in bonus bets for each of 7 qualifying days. Bonus bets expire in 7 days.
Recommended by NY BET
Promo CodeNo Promo Code needed
Visit site
21+, NY only. New customers. T&Cs apply.

What “hold” means in the NYSGC reports

Hold is gross gaming revenue divided by handle: the share of every dollar wagered that the sportsbook keeps after paying out winners. A 10% hold means bettors as a group got back $90 of every $100 they staked that week.

In New York, hold also drives the state’s take. Mobile sports wagering revenue is taxed at 51%, so the $63.3 million week was worth roughly $32.3 million to the state, by our calculation. That is the backdrop for every promo and price you see on a licensed NY sportsbook.

Three weeks of NFL data, operator by operator

Weekly numbers swing with results, so one week tells you little. Three straight weeks, set against a full fiscal year, tell you more.

OperatorWk ending Oct 4Wk ending Oct 11Wk ending Oct 18FY 2024-25
FanDuel10.3%9.1%12.1%10.54%
DraftKings6.4%9.2%10.0%8.46%
Fanatics7.0%9.7%8.5%7.48%
BetMGM7.0%5.3%7.7%7.10%
Caesars4.9%Nearly 9%8.2%9.09%
BetRivers7.8%9.2%5.7%6.85%
theScore Bet9.9%10.1%15.0%—
Bally Bet7.3%10.6%14.0%6.88%

FanDuel’s Oct. 4 figure is its $23.6 million revenue divided by its $228.2 million handle. theScore Bet does not appear in the FY 2024-25 operator figures.

Across those three weeks, FanDuel took $663.7 million in bets and kept $70.0 million, a 10.5% hold that sits almost exactly on its full-year 2024-25 rate. FanDuel also handled about 37% of statewide handle in the October 18 week and took 43% of revenue. That mismatch is the story in one line.

Parlays, pricing and player mix: why the gap persists

A sportsbook can’t choose who wins on Sunday. What it can shape is the kind of bets it takes and the prices it offers. Three things explain most of the spread.

Bet mix

Parlays and same-game parlays stack the book’s margin on every leg, so an app that pushes multi-leg bets hard will hold more over time than one built around single bets. If you love parlay betting, know that the extra payout comes with extra margin.

Pricing

Wider odds on straight bets lift hold slowly but steadily. Two books can post the same line with different juice, and over a season that difference shows up in the commission’s reports.

Who is betting

A book full of recreational players will hold more than one that attracts sharper bettors. Small operators also swing more. theScore Bet’s 15.0% hold came on just $7.9 million of handle, and Bally Bet’s 14.0% on $2.5 million. Samples that small say more about a handful of results than about pricing.

Our view: high hold has a cost for bettors

Persistent high hold isn’t proof that a book is a bad deal for every customer. But it does tell you where the market’s margin is concentrated. FanDuel has topped the state in hold over a full year, not just a hot week. BetMGM posted the lowest full-year hold of the five biggest books.

Flutter, FanDuel’s parent, admitted after the 2025 NFL season that hold has a downside. CEO Peter Jackson said FanDuel posted above-average margins in 10 of 11 weeks, that heavier losses made customers less willing to keep betting, and that its promotions didn’t keep pace. “We should’ve pushed harder,” he said.

For bettors, the takeaway is practical. Keep accounts at two or three books, compare prices on every moneyline bet, and save parlays for small, fun stakes. Whether you bet sides and totals at DraftKings, Caesars or anywhere else, the gap between the best and worst price on a given game is where your edge comes from.

NY sportsbook hold in 2027: our outlook

The fiscal-year data points to a market where handle grows faster than revenue. Over the first 30 weeks of FY 2026-27, New York handle reached $14.80 billion, up 6.2%, while revenue slipped about 1.0% to $1.31 billion. That puts hold at about 8.9%, down from roughly 9.5% at the same point a year earlier, by our calculation. The full 2024-25 fiscal year finished at 8.94%.

Our estimate for 2027: statewide hold stays in an 8.5% to 9.5% band, and FanDuel stays one to two points above the market. The basis is statewide hold of 8.98% in FY 2023-24, 8.94% in FY 2024-25 and about 8.9% so far this fiscal year, plus FanDuel’s consistent above-market margin. With a 51% tax unchanged, operators have little room to cut prices, so bettors who shop lines will gain more than those waiting for books to get more generous.

Sports betting in New York is for players 21 and older. If gambling stops being fun, call or text the HOPEline at 1-877-8-HOPENY, or visit our responsible gambling page.

More to read