Finger Lakes Race 5 Results & Payouts – Sep 23, 2026

Finger Lakes Race 5 results and payouts

Finish	Horse	Win	Place	Show
1	4 Signifying NothingKeiber Coa · T: Ralph D'Alessandro	$20.10	$4.32	$3.02
2	5 Cinnamon SugarAndre Worrie · T: Charlton Baker	–	$2.26	$2.10
3	7 Valentine GiftMichael Davila, Jr. · T: Timothy Murphy	–	–	$3.82

Finish

Horse

Win

Place

Show

4 Signifying NothingKeiber Coa · T: Ralph D'Alessandro

$20.10

$4.32

$3.02

5 Cinnamon SugarAndre Worrie · T: Charlton Baker

–

$2.26

$2.10

7 Valentine GiftMichael Davila, Jr. · T: Timothy Murphy

–

$3.82

Pick 3 2-4-4: $137.55 (pool $5,688)

Pick 5 1-ALL-2-4-4: $3,479.15 (pool $34,792)

Daily Double 4-4: $211.46 (pool $9,968)

Exacta 4-5: $39.06 (pool $52,778)

Superfecta 4-5-7-3: $28.47 (pool $19,661)

Trifecta 4-5-7: $35.93 (pool $32,258)

Time 1:06.01 · Track fast · Also ran: Cue the Music, Classiwest, Clarividente, Red Butterfly, Change Order, Hazard Pay

Race 5 field: morning lines and order of finish

#	Horse (sire – dam)	M/L	Jockey / trainer	Wt	Fin
3	Cue the MusicTapiture – Lyrical Tale	20-1	Jacqueline DavisT: Eduardo Maver, Jr.	122 lb
4	Signifying NothingCentral Banker – Time Counts	7-2	Keiber CoaT: Ralph D'Alessandro	122 lb	1
5	Cinnamon SugarInstagrand – Cinnamon Lass	5-2	Andre WorrieT: Charlton Baker	121 lb	2
6	Red ButterflyMunnings – Distortion	20-1	Wladimir RengifoT: Rachel Sells	112 lb
7	Valentine GiftBellamy Road – Birthday Gift	6-1	Michael Davila, Jr.T: Timothy Murphy	122 lb	3
8	ClassiwestClassic Empire – West Coast Girl	12-1	Emanuel De DiegoT: Katlynn Gutterson	122 lb
9	Hazard PayMaximus Mischief – Ms Dupree	20-1	Reylu GutierrezT: Glenroy Brown	122 lb
10	ClarividenteMaclean's Music – Aguadilla	5-1	Nazario AlvaradoT: Luis Gutierrez	121 lb
12	Change OrderVino Rosso – Impending Storm	20-1	Luis PerezT: Ilmar Loaiza	122 lb

M/L is the track handicapper’s morning line. Live tote odds replace it near post; results and $2 payouts appear once the race is official.

NY.bet picks for Race 5 at Finger Lakes

Top pick5 Cinnamon Sugar 5-2

The 5-2 morning-line favorite, so the track handicapper rates this horse as the one to beat.
Andre Worrie has won 12 of 57 rides (21%) at New York tracks in our records.
Trainer Charlton Baker is 4-for-33 (12%) in New York, with horses in the money 45% of the time.
By Instagrand out of Cinnamon Lass.

Value play12 Change Order 20-1

At 20-1 on the morning line, the price is bigger than this horse’s connections suggest.
Luis Perez has won 10 of 45 rides (22%) at New York tracks in our records.
Trainer Ilmar Loaiza is 4-for-16 (25%) in New York, with horses in the money 38% of the time.
By Vino Rosso out of Impending Storm.

Longshot8 Classiwest 12-1

A 12-1 outsider with enough in its corner to hit the board and juice an exotic.
Emanuel De Diego has won 6 of 40 rides (15%) at New York tracks in our records.
Trainer Katlynn Gutterson is 5-for-22 (23%) in New York, with horses in the money 32% of the time.
By Classic Empire out of West Coast Girl.

How our picks did

Top pick: Cinnamon Sugar (5-2) finished second.
Value play: Change Order (20-1) missed the board.
Longshot: Classiwest (12-1) missed the board.

Finger Lakes Race 5 analysis: pace, price and connections

Cinnamon Sugar is the 5-2 morning-line favorite, with Signifying Nothing next at 7-2. Prices stretch out to 20-1 on Change Order, so the board has real depth.

Among the riders, Luis Perez has the best New York strike rate in our records: 22% wins from 45 mounts.

Forecast: mostly sunny, high of 66°F.

How to place a bet on Finger Lakes Race 5 from New York

Online horse betting is legal in New York for adults 18 and over through licensed advance-deposit wagering (ADW) apps. You can bet Finger Lakes races from anywhere in the state, then watch and cash out in the app. Our partner AmWager offers new customers a 100% first deposit match up to $50. Read our AmWager review, or compare every NY racing app.

Finger Lakes visitor guide · NY sports betting apps · Official Finger Lakes site: race info, parking and hours